Home | Reviews | Articles | Festivals | Competitions | Other | Contact Us
Google
WWW MUSICALPOINTERS

HANDEL ALCINA Revival of production by David McVicar
ENO at The Coliseum, London 16 April 2003


Lisa Milne, Deanne Meek, Laura Claycomb, Charlotte Hellekant, Mark Richardson, Andrew Mackenzie-Wicks, Gail Pearson
conductor Richard Hickox
director David McVicar
set designer Michael Vale
costume designer Sue Blane
lighting designer Paule Constable
choreographers Michael Keegan-Dolan/Sarah Baron

In the original run of Alcina at ENO, conducted by Sir Charles MacKerras, I had been greatly taken by Lisa Milne as Alcina's sister, and her success in that role must have contributed to her elevation to the title role. I have more recently had concerns about her voice production (excessive vibrato etc) and felt that she is just not right for this role, but this is a matter of taste. Memories are fickle, but mine are good of Joan Rodgers in the title role, and especially of Sarah Connolly as a bewitched knight under Alcina's spell in this story of sorcery & transformation, one of Handel's 'magical' operas. In this revival, Deanne Meek from New York struts her stuff as Ruggiero, in a very welcome ENO debut, and the large cast of supporting soloists deal with Handel's exposed lines with confidence, enjoying the varied da capos and opportunities for flourishes at the ends of their arias; Laura Claycomb, Andrew Mackenzie-Wick and Charlotte Hellekant all making notable ENO debut appearances. The small orchestra allowed the voices to dominate with no strain; I did at times find Richard Hickox's tempi perilously slow.

To keep the eyes engaged, David McVicar has a huge number of visually entertaining conceits, countering the rationalism of a book-laden philosopher, Mark Richardson, who likes to play with mechanical toys, with Alcina's entourage of fancifully dressed attendants, who cavort around and climb all over the scenery athletically to keep boredom at bay.

The scenery of illusions is created on an imaginary island, Alcina's powers eventually destroyed and Handel's bust smashed to pieces, which perhaps gives a wrong message? On first viewing I was content to enjoy all the magical goings on without bothering too much about detailed references. Seeing it all again, I thought how fascinating it would be if McVicar had shared some of his thoughts about how he arrived at his own realisation to complement the lavishly illustrated historical essays in the programme book (c.f. the account of the director's thinking appended to my review of Handel's Susanna, recently staged at the Guildhall School of Music & Drama). The best deconstruction of this enchanting farrago is provided by Tim Ashley's review in The Guardian.


Original Production at ENO (1999) reviewed in Seen&Heard
:

ENO's Alcina on 29 November will be talked of in the future as one of those rare evenings at the opera when everything comes together and you feel anew that this is the finest of all the performance arts. This production is certain to be hugely popular and to present a real challenge to Covent Garden, now re-opening.

All the lead singers were excellent, negotiating their dazzling roulades with apparent ease whilst maintaining character through gesture and the most subtly choreographed movement. Joan Rodgers, surrounded by grotesque slinking spirits in attendance, sang the title role well throughout, and enjoyed numerous costume changes before finally becoming victim of her failing magical powers. I was greatly taken by Lisa Milne as Alcina's sister, who is quickly embroiled in cross dressing confusions, falling for a woman disguised as a man and singing with charm and accuracy whilst negotiating complicated stage movements, in a story of sorcery & transformation, one of Handel's 'magical' operas. Sarah Connolly, as a knight who eventually escapes Alcina's spell, has to present herself in masculine and feminine guise, and does so with equal authority in her carriage and her immaculate singing, perhaps the most memorable of them all.

Rather than praising all the singers individually, I prefer to list the director, David McVicar; Michael Vale, designer of the elaborate sets lit by Paule Constable, Sue Blane (costume designer), Michael Keegan-Dolan, (choreographer) and Amanda Holden (translator). The company style and ensemble was of a quality that, not many decades ago, was only to be found at Glyndebourne.

Sir Charles MacKerras conducted a performing version from a score prepared by Clifford Bartlett, editor of the Early Music Journal, which contrives to be both learned and entertaining, as was ENO's new Alcina. This costly production brought together allusions to the Age of Enlightment with eighteenth century fascination with magic and stage machinery. There are layers upon layers of allusions, discussed in the readable and fully illustrated programme book. Too clever by three-quarters, you might think, but it all meshes and works. Rather than attempting to describe the intricacies of McVicar's conception, I would urge people everywhere to make the journey to London to see ENO's 1999 Alcina. A palpable hit!
PGW

See also: Alcina on Arthaus DVD by Peter Grahame Woolf in The Opera Critic.

HANDEL Alcina
Catherine Naglestad, Alice Coote, Helene Schneidermann, Catriona Smith, Rolf Romei, Michael Ebbecke, Claudia Mahnke, Heinz Gerger
Staatorchester Stuttgart - conductor: Alan Hacker
Stage Directors: Jossi Wieler & Sergio Morabito
Director for Video: Janos Darvas
Region 0. PCM stereo, Widescreen, Subtitled
Live from Staatsoper Stuttgart 1999

Arthaus 100 338 [159 mins]


This updated Alcina has given me inordinate pleasure and we have watched and listened to it twice (you need to, to sort out the story line!). - - Don't miss giving it a try.

© Peter Grahame Woolf